[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

varicella vaccine

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
This message is from PedTalk!  To reply to the group, use ""
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I don't dispute that 1) the vaccine is effective 2) the vaccine is
safe.  3) that it may spare the lives of 50-100 children a year who
might die of varicella complications.  My problem is that one of the
main reasons this was justified by the Red Book committee is the
"cost-effectiveness" based on a few (3!!) studies using some
epidmiologic/economic modelling techniques.
	Given a cohort of about 3 million kids a year who would need
vaccination, at roughly $50 a pop, we're talking about $150 million A
YEAR to prevent 50-100 deaths.  Right off the top of my head I can think
of a bunch of ways that money could be spent to save a heck of a lot
more lives.