[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Babywise debate

In a message dated 98-05-23 01:41:03 EDT, you write:

<< There's a name for children who are not given age appropriate
 discipline:  spoiled brat.



 I'm a little sensitive to lack of discipline now.  A four year old in my
 practice probably has ambylopia but will not cooperate for the
 ophthalmologist because, according to his mother, &quot;he doesn't want
 to.&quot;  This child has been a terror his whole life, I don't think the
 word &quot;NO&quot; has ever passed his mother's lips, and the child is
 the one who has suffered because of it.&nbsp; She finally admitted at the
 most recent visit that, well, maybe, he's a little spoiled.  Well, it's
 never too late to start appropriate discipline, but by age four this
 child has already developed a pattern which would be really hard
 to reverse even by a parent who does have a backbone.





 Michael Sachs, M.D.

 General Pediatrician
 >>
I would be VERY surprised to find out that what "ruined" this spoiled (4 yr
old) child that has always been a terror is on-demand feedings and un-
conditional love....children who lack discipline and get "spoiled" are usually
somehow deprived of their fundamental needs, yet supplemented instead with a
material want or act of leniency (toy rewards for potty -training, candy
instead of dinner food,  staying up 3 hours past bedtime, not having to pick
up toys, being allowed to hit a friend without a time-out and an apology,
etc...) I have yet to see a child who's fundamental needs were met, end up a
spoiled brat.  Is it a fundamental need to be breastfed in the middle of the
night as a 6 month old? YOU BET!  I don't think there is anything wrong with
this even at the age of 18 months (and neither does the LLL, or the Center For
Breastfeeding Information)...Nursing doesn't occur just because of hunger!
Children nurse for closeness, comfort, because they had a bad dream, because
they are teething, becuase they have a cold and need soothing, because they
want to suck, because they love to be near by and loved....what could possibly
be wrong with these things???  My children are two of the most well behaved
kids I have ever seen; we get comments daily from strangers marveling at their
good behavior, yet they sleep with my husband and I, and are both nursed
whenever they request it (and no, we don't loose sleep because they are so
close by). Who do my kids turn to when they need love and comfort? Who do they
know will always have time for them, and always puts them first?? Their
parents, if course. And I bet you anything, in 12 years...when they are
miserable teenageers....that's who they still will be turning to when there
are very difficult issues and decisions to face; drugs, sex, violence,
etc....But, if kids learn at an early age that mom and dad aren't always there
to meet their needs, than what?  Well, IMHO...that's when they'll get a little
pissy one day and go blow the heads off of a couple of schoolmates....you get
out what you put in; and if you aren't willing to invest 100%...DON'T HAVE
KIDS!
Adriana Samargia Kaufman
Precious Delivery Birth Services