[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Pediatric Chiropractic

Thanks to all for responses. To summarise my feelings on the matter:

1) This prime issue around chiropractic (and other pseudosciences) is the
adherence to a belief system. In the case of chiro. it is based on the
theory that health is controlled through minimal spinal subluxations and
their effect on spinal nerves. Because the entire "profession" rests on this
theory it cannot be critically appraised by it's followers lest the whole
thing fall down. In contrast, "traditional" MDs should not adhere to
theories/treatments that no longer stand up to scrutiny - I have accordingly
given up on blood letting, thymic irradiation, theophylline for asthma
(except in unusual circumstances) etc etc. - you get the point. By the same
token, I will gladly use any method of treatment that has been substantiated
and found safe by a rational scientific process, whether it is Ginko Baloba,
kava kava, Efalex, or any other "treatment" du jour.

2) I want parents to choose between "conventional" medicine and the mumbo
jumbo being offered by the chiropractor. If this is not made clear then I am
tacitly collaborating in a treatment program that I know to be of no value
and fraudulent. This also applies to refloxology, iridology and whatever
else is popular tomorrow.

3) I try to offer parents a clear understanding of a condition and it's
natural history, not cook up some nonsense about spinal nerve and
subluxations. Most OM will resolve although I can prevent mastoiditis and
other complications with antibiotics where this is appropriate. Colic always
does resolve, with or without an expensive back rub.

4) Take a look at the chiropractic literature on colic and otitis (as
examples) and see an incredible paucity of any studies. The studies on
Medline are so woefully inadequate they are laughable (retrospective,
anecdotal, uncontrolled, non-randomised, unblinded and so on).

"Isn't it amazing how some people will embrace a ludicrous delusion rather
than face a bleak truth" - paraphrased from "Calvin and Hobbes" - my heroes.

Have a good New Year, one and all.
Steve
Steve Wainer MD FRCPC
Calgary