[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

rebuttals to co-sleeping warning

http://www.salon.com/mwt/feature/1999/09/30/family_bed_rant/index.html

www.lalecheleague.org/Release/cosleeping.html

LA LECHE LEAGUE INTERNATIONAL AND CO-SLEEPING EXPERT FIND
      STUDY TO BE INACCURATE

      Contact: Kim Cavaliero, (847) 519-7730 ext. 233, Mary Lofton ext.
271, or Mary Hurt ext. 271

      FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

      Schaumburg, IL (September 30, 1999) - La Leche League
International (LLLI), the world's foremost authority on breastfeeding,
questioned the results of a recent study published in the Archives of
Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine which refers to co-sleeping as an
unsafe practice for families.

      Studies have shown that co-sleeping with a breastfeeding infant
promotes bonding, regulates the mother and
      baby's sleep patterns, plays a role in helping the mother to
become more responsive to her baby's cues, and gives both the mother and
baby needed rest. The co-sleeping environment also assists mothers in
the continuation of breastfeeding on demand, an important step in
maintaining the mother's milk supply.

      Dr. James McKenna, Professor of Anthropology at the University of
Notre Dame, a member of LLLI's Health Advisory Council, and an expert on
the subject of co-sleeping, believes there to be more danger in leaving
an infant alone in a crib than in arranging a safe co-sleeping
environment. He states, "We agree with the authors and others that
special precautions need to be taken to minimize catastrophic accidents.
However, the need for such precautions is no more an argument against
all co-sleeping and, specifically bedsharing, than is the reality of
infants accidentally strangling, suffocating, or dying from SIDS alone
in cribs, a reason to recommend against all solitary, unsupervised
infant sleep." He adds, "While specific structural hazards of an adult
bed are important, the fact that they exist means neither that they
cannot be eliminated nor that all bed-sharing is unsafe." Dr. McKenna
also considers the conclusions and recommendations of the study to be
inappropriate because the authors based their findings on incomplete and
anecdotal evidence rather than hard scientific data.

      Dr. McKenna believes that co-sleeping can be a positive experience
for a breastfeeding family and should not be considered dangerous if
parents institute the following safeguards:

     Parents should not sleep with their babies if they are smokers or
have ingested alcohol or drugs.

     Bedding should be tight fitting to the mattress.

     The mattress should be tight fitting to the headboard of the bed.

     There should not be any loose pillows or soft blankets near the
baby's face.

     There should not be any space between the bed and adjoining wall
where the baby could roll and become trapped.

      The baby should not be placed on its stomach.

      La Leche League International offers mother-to-mother support,
education, and information in 66 countries, and 28 languages, around the
world. In addition, LLLI offers a variety of additional educational
programs for medical professionals, as well as publishing and selling
books and magazines about breastfeeding and parenting. LLLI also
maintains an award-winning Web site at www.lalecheleague.org.

Janet V