[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Cosleeping safety guidelines

Why does the La Leche League International take such a strong
stand on co-sleeping? I thought the focus was on breast
feeding. I know of a recent local death due to co-sleeping,
and I am sure others on the list know of cases. Why "dilute"
an excellent adjunct to child rearing (breast feeding) with a
potentially fatal and unnecessary practice? What's the point?
Saying something like " There are ways to make co-sleeping
safer" is the same thing as saying it must be un-safe to start
with. And remember, we are promoting breast feeding to the
un-washed masses. If you recommend co-sleeping to the
un-enlightened, infants will die. Saying "Just because there
have been accidents..." is saying "Just because a few babies
died..." I think the use of the word "accident" is missing the
point. Most people think you put Band-Aids on "accidents". You
bury co-sleeping "accidents".
Stick to the main program. Promote breast feeding. Make babies
healthier - not at greater risk.
As far as for the "authors who believe that co-sleeping may
reduce the risk of
SIDS" , remember when the articles pointing out the risk of
SIDS associated with prone sleeping first appeared, lots of
american experts were poo-pooing it saying it did not apply to
AMERICAN babies. Right. Beware of experts with vested
interests.
-g barden



JVandenberg wrote:
>
> There are ways to make co-sleeping safer.  Just because there have been
> accidents does not mean that the whole practice of co-sleeping should be
> abandoned:
>
>  -  if using alcohol, recreational drugs, or medications that cause
> drowsiness, or are experiencing extreme exhaustion, a parent may find
> that they are less likely to be aware of baby?s presence in the bed. If
> partner is less responsive or aware, can avoid placing baby between
> parents and place baby on the other side instead.
>  ? mattresses -  it may be of benefit to use a firm mattress with well
> fitting covers
>  ? minimize the use of extra pillows and blankets which could reduce the
> airflow to baby
>  ? waterbeds can be a hazard - can reduce the risk by adding a firm
> board under baby.
>  ? avoid falls - can place the bed against the wall & place child
> between mother and the wall, use a crib or a safety rail beside the bed
> or place the mattress on the floor. Beware of entrapment dangers and pad
> any spaces.
> -remove headboard or footboards if they have bars with spaces larger
> than 6 cm
>  ? use couches with caution - baby may become caught between gaps in
> cushions
>  ? very large breasted or very obese mothers may need to use careful
> positioning of baby at the breast if sleeping while baby is nursing to
> ensure baby has a clear area to breathe.
>  ? adjust sleeping arrangements as needed as baby develops new skills -
> rolling over, crawling, climbing
>
> There are authors who believe that co-sleeping may reduce the risk of
> SIDS.
> References:
>
> McKenna, Sarah Mosko, & Christopher Richards
>
> Breastfeeding infants have more arousels while cosleeping & spend less
> time in the deep stage of sleep from which some infants have difficulty
> arousing. When a period of apnea occurs, the baby will arouse to breath.
> A baby who has difficulty arousing may be at greater risk for a SIDS
> event
> Cosleeping regulates infants breathing, sleep state, arousal patterns,
> heart rates, & body temperature.
>
> McKenna, J., Babies Need Their Mothers Beside Them, [Online] Available
> March 25, 1999:  http://www.naturalchild.com/guest/james_mckenna.html.
>
> McKenna, J., Rethinking "Healthy" Infant Sleep, [Online] Available March
> 25, 1999:
>   http://www.parenthoodweb.com/library/RethinkingSleep.htm
>
> McKenna, J., Mosko, S., Dungy, C., McAninch, J., Sleep and arousal
> patterns of co-sleeping human mother/infant pairs: a preliminary
> physiological study with implications for the study of sudden infant
> death syndrome (SIDS), Am J Phys Anthropol, 83(3):331-47 1990 Nov.
>
> McKenna J; Mosko S., Richard C., Bedsharing promotes breastfeeding,
>  Pediatrics, 100(2 Pt 1):214-9 1997 Aug.
>
> McKenna J; Mosko S; Richard C; Drummond S; Hunt L; Cetel MB; Arpaia J,
> Experimental
>  studies of infant-parent co-sleeping: mutual physiological and
> behavioral influences
>  and their relevance to SIDS (sudden infant death syndrome), Early Hum
> Dev,
>  38(3):187-201 1994 Sep 15
>
> Sears, W. SIDS: A parents guide to understanding and preventing sudden
> infant death syndrome, New York: Little Brown & Company, 1995.
>
> Janet Vandenberg BScN, RN, IBCLC
>